All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

What Is a Valued Policy?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

A valued policy is an insurance contract that fixes the payout in advance: the scheduled or agreed value is paid at total loss regardless of the item's actual cash value. It is the exception to indemnity's restore-but-never-enrich rule — and collector-car agreed-value policies and scheduled floaters are where consumers meet it.

How it works

The schedule is the contract. An appraisal at issue sets the agreed value; at a total loss, that number pays — no depreciation argument, no comparable-sales negotiation. Underwriting controls the moral hazard (scheduling an item above its real worth) with appraisals, re-appraisal cycles, and usage restrictions such as the collector car's limited-use clause — the daily commute that voids the agreed-value form.

The consumer forms: the classic-car agreed-value policy, the scheduled personal property floater for jewelry and art, fine-art policies with agreed-value terms, and commercial inland-marine floaters for scheduled equipment. Partial losses break the pattern — most agreed-value policies pay repair cost with like-kind parts and no depreciation, but the partial-loss rules vary by form, so the settlement language deserves a read. The valuation risk runs in one direction only: a stale schedule pays its old number, and the appreciation gap belongs to the owner — the 2019 appraisal value pays in 2025. Appreciating assets need the re-appraisal discipline the policy asks for; depreciating ones rarely do, because the schedule starts generous and the risk runs the carrier's way instead. The appraisal itself is the gate: a fresh, itemized valuation at issue is what makes the schedule enforceable on both sides.

Typical values

ContextTypical value
Classic-car agreed valueThe appraised figure (example: $85,000)
Agreed-value policy costCommonly $400–$600 per year for a collector car
Re-appraisal cycleCommonly every 3–5 years
Scheduled floatersItem-level schedules, often no deductible

Valued policy vs indemnity policy

The standard property policy pays indemnity — actual loss, computed as actual cash value or replacement cost, capped at the limit: insurance restores, never enriches. The valued policy replaces that computation with a number agreed in advance, which is why appraisals gate it. A third form muddies the water: stated amount coverage declares a value but often settles at the lower of stated or ACV — a cap, not a guarantee. Some states' older valued-policy statutes required full scheduled-value payment on total losses of real property regardless of actual value — consumer-protection laws from the era of ACV disputes — but modern rating and forms have largely superseded them, and today's consumer encounters the concept almost exclusively in the collector and scheduled-property markets.

Worked example

A 1967 Mustang carries an agreed-value policy with the value set at $85,000 by appraisal. A total-loss fire pays $85,000 — no depreciation applied, no comparable sales argued — and the salvage passes per the policy's terms. The standard-policy alternative would have paid from book value: roughly $32,000 of actual cash value for the same car. The agreed-value premium ran about $450 per year, and the owner's duties were the trade: annual usage inside the policy's clause, appraisal updates after the restoration, and the 3–5-year re-appraisal cycle that keeps the schedule honest.

Valued policies sit in the valuation family — the standards they replace and the scheduled-property products they resemble.

Frequently asked questions

What is a valued policy?

A contract that fixes the payout in advance: the scheduled or agreed value pays at total loss regardless of the item's actual cash value. Collector-car agreed-value policies and scheduled jewelry floaters are the common forms. Standard policies instead pay indemnity — actual loss, capped at the limit.

Why do valued policies require appraisals?

Because the schedule is the payout — the appraisal sets it and keeps it honest. Carriers require current appraisals at issue and re-appraisal cycles (commonly every 3–5 years) for appreciating items. An under-scheduled item pays its stale value; the appreciation gap belongs to the owner.

What's the difference between agreed value and stated amount?

Agreed value pays the scheduled number at a total loss, period. Stated amount is a cap, not a guarantee — many stated-amount forms settle at the lower actual cash value. The settlement language in the form decides, so read it before assuming the declared number is what pays.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.