All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

What Is Underinsured Motorist Coverage?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

Underinsured motorist (UIM) coverage pays your injury damages when the at-fault driver's liability limits are too low — their policy pays first to its limit, and your UIM coverage picks up the remaining damages up to your own limit. It protects your household against the driver who obeyed the law and still cannot pay.

How it works

The claim has an extra legal step that a normal liability claim does not: exhaustion. The at-fault carrier's limits must be tendered — paid to their limit — before your UIM coverage engages. Your carrier then values the remaining damages the way a liability claimant would: medical records, wage loss, future care, and pain and suffering, negotiated adversarially even though it is your own carrier paying.

Three mechanics shape the payout:

  • Consent-to-settle clauses — settling the liability claim without your carrier's written consent can forfeit the UIM claim; the sequence is tender, consent, then settle.
  • Reduction formulas — most states subtract the amount actually collected from the at-fault driver; some subtract their policy limits even if less was paid. The difference is money.
  • Stacking — in states that permit it, multi-vehicle households can add UIM limits across vehicles: two cars at 100/300 can mean $200,000/$600,000 of injury protection.

UIM pairs with uninsured motorist (UM) coverage as the two lines answering the other driver's inadequacy, and the premium delta from minimums to matched limits commonly runs $30–$100 per year. Where no UIM election exists, uninsured motorist property damage (UMPD) handles the property side in the states that offer it.

Typical values

ContextTypical value
Recommended UIM limitsMatch liability: 100/300
Premium delta, minimums to matched limits$30–$100 per year
TriggerAt-fault limits tendered first
Stacking statesLimits add across household vehicles
Forfeiture trapSettling the liability claim without written consent

Underinsured motorist vs uninsured motorist

UIM pays when the at-fault driver's liability limits are exhausted before your damages are; UM pays when there are no applicable limits at all — the hit-and-run driver or the uninsured driver. The trigger documents differ: UIM claims require proof the at-fault limits were tendered; UM claims require proof the driver carried nothing (or was never identified). Both lines ride one coverage election on most policies, and the standard recommendation — matching your UIM limits to your own bodily injury liability — applies to both.

Worked example

A crash causes $180,000 in injuries. The at-fault driver carries 25/50 state minimums — legal everywhere, and $25,000 is the most their carrier will ever pay. The victim's UIM limit is $250,000: the tender of $25,000 exhausts the at-fault coverage, the UIM claim evaluates the remaining $155,000 of damages, and the victim's carrier pays it within the limit. Without UIM, the $155,000 gap is collected — or not — from the at-fault driver personally, against a driver whose assets rarely fund it. In a reduction-formula state that subtracts policy limits rather than amounts paid, the arithmetic would not change here; where the at-fault carrier tendered less than its limits, the formula choice would move the recovery by thousands.

UIM sits in the fault-based injury-coverage family — the liability lines it mirrors and the first-party medical coverages it coordinates with.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How does an underinsured motorist claim work?

First the at-fault driver's carrier pays to its policy limits (the tender), then your own carrier evaluates the remaining damages and pays up to your UIM limit. The catch: most policies require your carrier's written consent before you settle the liability claim — settling without it can forfeit the UIM recovery entirely.

What's the right UIM limit to carry?

The standard recommendation is matching your bodily injury liability limits — 100/300 liability with 100/300 UIM. The coverage pays your own household's injury gap; carrying less UIM than liability protects strangers more than your family. The premium delta from state minimums to matched limits commonly runs $30–$100 per year.

Should I carry UIM if I have health insurance?

Yes. UIM pays damages health insurance never touches — lost wages and pain and suffering — and your health plan's lien often claims part of any settlement, shrinking the medical side further. UIM is priced cheaply because the exposure it covers (the legally-insured-but-underinsured driver) is common.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.