All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

What Is an At-Fault Accident?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

An at-fault accident is a crash in which the driver bears legal responsibility — their bodily injury and property damage liability pay the other side, their collision pays their own car, and the claim surcharges their premium at renewal. Fault comes from police reports, adjuster investigations, and state negligence rules.

How it works

The fault determination decides whose insurance pays whom — and whose premium moves. Police report citations, scene evidence, and the adjusters' liability conversation produce the finding; in comparative-negligence states, comparative negligence rules split fault by percentage, and 20% fault means your carrier pays 20% of the other side's damages. The determination on the report is influential but not binding — carriers arbitrate disputes between themselves.

The pricing consequence: carriers surcharge at-fault claims commonly 20–40% for three years on the liability and collision portions, longer for severe events and DUI-tier violations. The claim populates your motor vehicle record and your claims history regardless of forgiveness or fault. Not-at-fault claims generally carry no surcharge — several states prohibit it outright — though the claim entry still appears.

Typical values

ParameterTypical value
Premium surchargeCommonly 20–40% for three years
Record windowsMVR: 3–5 years; CLUE claim history: up to 7 years
Not-at-fault surcharge0–10% at most carriers; prohibited in some states
Small at-fault claimsUnder about $1,000 — often worth paying out of pocket
RecoverySurcharge declines annually and ages off; re-shop at each milestone

At-fault vs not-at-fault accident

At fault: your bodily injury liability and property damage lines pay the other side, your collision pays your car, and the surcharge schedule fires. Not at fault: the other driver's liability pays you (or your collision pays and then subrogates), and most carriers apply no surcharge. One at-fault event can also be mitigated: accident forgiveness excludes a first at-fault accident from the rating at many carriers.

Worked example

An at-fault rear-end collision lands on a $1,450 per year premium. The renewal applies a 32% surcharge: $1,914. Year 2 drops about 8%, year 3 drops 12%, and year 4 the surcharge ages off — the re-shop at that milestone restores the $1,450 baseline. Skipping the milestone re-shops leaves the aging surcharge priced into every quote the market sees.

The fault determination feeds a chain of records and coverages — the terms below decide what the crash actually costs.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How much does an at-fault accident raise my insurance?

Carriers commonly apply a 20–40% surcharge for three years on the liability and collision portions, with wide carrier-to-carrier dispersion for the same event. Severe claims and DUI-tier events run higher. The exact number comes from each carrier's surcharge schedule — which is why the post-accident quote comparison is standard advice.

Does a not-at-fault accident affect my insurance?

The claim still posts to your record, but most carriers apply no surcharge or a light one for not-at-fault events. Exceptions exist: uninsured at-fault parties (your uninsured-motorist claim), high claim frequency, and some states allow surcharges regardless of fault. A violation attached to the crash matters more than the claim itself.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.