All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

How Long Do Claims Affect Insurance?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

Claims history is the cross-carrier record of every insurance claim you filed or had filed against you — reported to industry bureaus, pulled by carriers at quote and renewal, and priced for 3–7 years depending on the line of business. Denied and sub-deductible claims populate the record just like paid ones.

How it works

Carriers report claim activity to industry databases: the CLUE report for personal property and auto, ISO's A-PLUS as the competing bureau, loss run reports for commercial accounts, and the motor vehicle record for driving events. Underwriters read the entries at three checkpoints: quoting, renewal pricing, and application verification. The application question "claims in the past five years" must match the bureau record — mismatches become misrepresentation findings that support rescission. Frequency weighs as heavily as severity: three small entries price a file harder than one large payment. Denied claims appear on some reports too, because a filed claim is recorded whether or not it paid.

Typical values

Line of businessPricing effect window
Auto claims3–5 years
Property claims (CLUE)5–7 years
Workers comp experience modificationAbout 3 years of data per rating cycle
Bureau report retentionSeven years common

Bureau entries list the claim date, carrier, loss amount, and cause, so a theft or water claim prices differently than a glass claim of the same size. The aging-off date is the re-shopping trigger — a surcharge that survived two renewals can vanish at the third, but only if you re-quote.

Claims history vs driving record

Claims history is what insurance paid; the driving record is what the state recorded. Underwriters buy both, and they answer different questions about the same driver.

AttributeClaims historyDriving record (MVR)
SourceCarrier reports to bureausState motor vehicle agency
CoversClaims across carriers and propertiesViolations and reportable accidents
RetentionSeven years common on bureau reportsThree to seven years by state

A crash can appear on both files, on one, or on neither — the MVR records the citation, the bureau records the payout, and carriers reconcile the two.

Common mistakes

  • Filing claims barely above the deductible — a $1,200 claim against a $1,000 deductible nets $200 and can add surcharges for three years
  • Skipping the free annual disclosure that catches erroneous entries before quotes price them in
  • Answering application questions from memory instead of from the bureau record
  • Marking the aging-off date without actually re-quoting when it passes

Worked example

A homeowner files three claims in five years: a $900 theft (paid), a $1,200 water claim (paid), and an $800 hail claim (denied). The CLUE history shows three entries. The renewal arrives with a 22% surcharge; competing quotes return two declines and one offer 40% above the prior premium. The three entries priced the policy more than the $2,100 of payments the carrier actually made — the quotes-before-filing discipline would have preserved the record.

Claims history is the input; the neighboring entries are the files carriers read it from and the decisions it feeds.

Frequently asked questions

Do claims follow me when I switch insurance carriers?

Yes — carriers report claims to industry bureaus, and new carriers pull those reports when you quote. The claim's date, payment, and cause travel with you across carriers for roughly seven years on property and auto reports. Application questions also obligate disclosure, so switching does not reset the record.

Do glass-only or roadside claims affect my claims history?

They can — filing practices vary by carrier, and some carriers report every claim regardless of size while others exclude glass and towing from rating. The safest assumption is that any filed claim appears on the report. Carriers that exclude small claims from rating still see the entry and weigh the frequency pattern.

How do I dispute an error in my claims history?

Request your free annual disclosures from the bureaus — LexisNexis for CLUE and ISO for A-PLUS — and file a dispute with supporting documentation. For commercial loss runs, request the correction from the carrier that reported the claim. Corrections flow back to carriers, and the corrected file quotes differently.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.