All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

What Do Medicare Star Ratings Mean?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

Medicare Star Ratings are CMS's annual 1-to-5 quality scores for Medicare Advantage and Part D plans, built from roughly 40 measures spanning clinical outcomes, member experience, complaints, customer service, and drug safety. The ratings publish each October before open enrollment, and 5-star plans can be joined any month.

How it works

CMS aggregates the measures into a plan-level composite and releases the ratings each October for the following year, based on the prior year's data. The scores drive money and rights in both directions: 4-star-plus ratings unlock quality bonus payments that commonly fund richer benefits, and a plan below 3 stars for three consecutive years lands on a watch list.

The member-facing rule is the 5-star special enrollment: once per year — commonly from early December into the following spring — a beneficiary can switch into a 5-star Advantage or Part D plan outside the normal windows, a form of special enrollment period built into the program. The ratings are the one government-calculated, not marketed, comparison in the shopping tools.

Ratings measure the plan product, not the county — the same carrier's HMO and PPO products in one county can rate differently, and employer-group plans receive no stars. Medigap carries none either, because standardized letter benefits leave nothing to measure; see Medicare Advantage for the products the stars attach to.

Typical values

ItemTypical value
Scale1 to 5 stars, whole stars, annual
MeasuresRoughly 40 across outcomes, experience, complaints, access
PublicationEach October, for the following year
Bonus threshold4 stars and above unlock quality bonus payments
Watch listBelow 3 stars for three consecutive years
5-star switch windowOnce per year, commonly December into spring

Star ratings vs plan price

Ratings measure quality; premium measures cost — the two axes are independent. A 5-star plan can carry a high premium, and a cheap plan can rate poorly. The practical use: treat ratings as the tiebreaker between priced-equal plans, read the measure-level scores for conditions relevant to the household (diabetes care, rheumatoid arthritis management), and re-check each October because the scores move annually.

Worked example

A beneficiary compares two Advantage plans for 2027: Plan A (3.5 stars, $0 premium, narrow network) and Plan B (4.5 stars, $38 per month, broader network, higher complaint-free scores). The $38 premium buys documented service quality, and the 4.5-star plan's bonus-funded benefit grid shows where the extras sit. Neither rating decided alone — the ratings anchored the comparison with government-verified data.

Where the ratings appear in practice

The Medicare Plan Finder displays the star rating beside every Advantage and Part D plan — the most visible quality signal in the shopping interface. CMS publishes the full release each October with measure-level detail, and carriers advertise ratings in the Annual Notice of Change and marketing materials; a 5-star label is a carrier's strongest marketing asset. The claim-side effect is indirect: bonus-funded benefits print in the plan's benefit grid, and the 5-star switch window lets a member move into a 5-star plan once per year, commonly from early December into the following spring.

Star ratings are one input in the annual Medicare shopping cycle — the neighbors cover the products and pillars they measure.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

How are Medicare Star Ratings calculated?

CMS scores roughly 40 measures — clinical outcomes, screening rates, member experience, complaints, and appeals timeliness — into a 1-to-5 plan-level rating published each October for the following year. Plans below 3 stars for three consecutive years land on a watch list, and 4-star-plus ratings unlock quality bonus payments that fund richer benefits.

What does a 5-star Medicare plan get me?

A special enrollment right: once per year, commonly from early December into the following spring, you can switch into a 5-star Advantage or Part D plan outside the normal windows. The plan itself commonly offers richer benefits funded by quality bonuses. The switch right does not apply to Medigap.

Do Medigap plans have star ratings?

No — Medigap benefits are standardized by plan letter, so there is no benefit variation for CMS to measure. The shopping variable for Medigap is price across carriers for the identical letter plan; star ratings measure only Medicare Advantage and Part D products.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.