All About InsuranceGuides · Costs · Choices
Menu

Glossary

What Is a Financial Strength Rating?

By Daniel Reyes, AINS, former licensed P&C agentLead insurance writerFact-checkedUpdated · Reviewed by Marcus Hale, CPCU, AINS, licensed P&C agent

A financial strength rating is an independent agency's grade of an insurer's ability to pay claims — including claims decades in the future. AM Best's scale runs A++ down to F; S&P and Moody's publish equivalents. The rating is the decisive check on any policy with a distant payout: life insurance, annuities, long-term care.

How it works

The agencies analyze capital adequacy, reserve strength, investment portfolios, and reinsurance, then grade the underwriting entity — not the marketing brand. AM Best's scale is the insurance specialist's: A++ and A+ are Superior, A and A- are Excellent, B++ and B+ are Good, and grades below B mark Vulnerable companies. S&P and Moody's rate on their own letter scales, and the consumer use is a floor: A- or better is the sane minimum for long-duration promises, while B++ is commonly tolerable for annual-repricing auto and home policies behind state guaranty backstops. Ratings also reach the pool behind the pool — reinsurers carry their own grades, and a carrier's program leans on them. For the buyer, one check order works: state license first, rating second, price last.

The rating also moves. Demotions precede market exits, non-renewal waves, and acquisitions, so rating news on your own carrier is worth reading. Outlooks and watch lists move before the rating does, so a carrier on CreditWatch is already a repricing candidate — and surplus lines carriers are often unrated by design, with statutory diligence substituting for the agency grade. The verification path: the AM Best lookup, the carrier's ratings page, and the "underwritten by" line that names the actual issuing carrier. Cross-agency comparisons stay rough — AM Best's A+ maps near S&P's A+, but the agencies weight reinsurance and catastrophe exposure differently.

Typical values

AM Best scaleMeaning
A++ / A+Superior — the standard for life, annuities, LTC
A / A-Excellent — the floor for long-duration promises
B++ / B+Good — commonly acceptable for auto and home
B and belowVulnerable — treat the price as the risk

Financial strength rating vs customer-satisfaction ratings

Financial strength grades solvency; J.D. Power scores and the NAIC complaint index grade the service experience. The two are separate axes: the A++ carrier with slow claims service, the B++ carrier with beloved service. Weight them by product. Life and annuity purchases are 40-year promises where the rating is the product; standard auto reprices yearly and sits behind guaranty floors, where the discount from a lower-rated carrier is a defensible trade. Mutual companies and surplus lines carriers — often unrated or lower-rated — serve markets where the rating floor bends; reinsurance programs back some of them.

Worked example

A 30-year-old quotes a 40-year term policy: the A+-rated carrier prices $310 per month, an unrated carrier $240 per month. The $70 per month buys the solvency confidence behind a benefit payable around age 70 — four decades of carrier-solvency exposure. For a 12-month auto policy, the same discount calculus favors the cheaper quote, because annual repricing limits the exposure window and the guaranty association caps the downside.

The rating is a carrier-selection input, and the neighboring pages — what a carrier is, where ratings appear in shopping, how solvency is backstopped — complete the decision.

Sources

Frequently asked questions

What financial strength rating should my insurance company have?

For life insurance and annuities — promises that run decades — A+ or better from AM Best is the standard advice. For auto and home policies, which reprice annually and sit behind state guaranty backstops, B++ and above is commonly acceptable. The cheaper quote's rating is the trade you are pricing.

What happens if my insurance company goes bankrupt?

The state guaranty association steps in: property/casualty claims are typically covered to $300,000–$500,000 per claim, life death benefits to $300,000, and cash value to $100,000, per state limits. Coverage survives the insolvency at the guaranty floor — which is why long-duration products deserve top-rated carriers rather than the floor.

How do I check an insurer's financial strength rating?

AM Best publishes a free lookup at ambest.com, and carriers print their ratings on their own sites. Verify the underwriting entity, not the marketing brand — the rating attaches to the carrier that issues the policy, and the brand name on the quote may sit atop a different underwriter.

Does a financial strength rating measure customer service?

No. Financial strength grades the carrier's ability to pay claims decades from now — capital, reserves, investments. Customer-satisfaction ratings grade the service experience, and the NAIC complaint index tracks complaints. The two are separate axes, and a carrier can score well on one and poorly on the other.

← Back to the full insurance glossary

Sources

The primary sources behind the facts on this page. Last verified November 10, 2026.

Rules that vary by state are verified against the state insurance department's consumer pages — find yours via the NAIC directory above.